Resume and JobRESUME AND JOB
Papa Johns logo

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!

Papa Johns

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!

full-timePosted: Feb 4, 2026

Job Description

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!

Join the Papa Johns team as a Shift Leader in New Carlisle, Ohio, and bring your flavor to one of the best food service jobs in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344. Papa Johns is hiring in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 for dynamic leaders ready to make a difference in the pizza industry. This is more than a job; it's a career pathway in a thriving restaurant environment where your skills can shine.

About the Role

As a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio, you'll step into a leadership position that's perfect for motivated individuals passionate about team success and exceptional customer service. Located at 410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344, this role involves overseeing daily operations during your shift, ensuring every pizza is crafted with our legendary quality, and every customer leaves with a smile. Papa Johns Shift Leaders are the backbone of our stores, blending hands-on pizza making with managerial oversight to deliver the Papa Johns difference.

In this fast-paced yet rewarding position, you'll manage a team of 5-15 team members, handle orders, maintain inventory, and uphold our high standards of cleanliness and efficiency. Jobs in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 like this one offer flexible scheduling, competitive pay, and the chance to grow within a national brand. Whether you're coordinating deliveries or training new hires, your impact will be felt immediately in our close-knit New Carlisle community.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just a pizza company; we're a family committed to 'Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.' Founded in 1984, we've grown to over 5,000 locations worldwide, but our heart remains in creating genuine connections. At our New Carlisle, Ohio location on 410 N Main St, you'll be part of a culture that values teamwork, integrity, and fun. We celebrate diversity, encourage work-life balance, and invest in your development through ongoing training programs.

Our company culture emphasizes employee growth – over 80% of our store managers started in entry-level roles like team member or shift leader. Enjoy perks like employee discounts on meals, flexible hours that fit your life, and a supportive environment where your voice matters. Papa Johns hiring in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 means joining a brand that's consistently ranked among the top in customer satisfaction. Experience the pride of working for a company that gives back to communities through fundraisers and local events right here in New Carlisle.

Team Spirit and Recognition

We foster a positive vibe with team-building events, performance bonuses, and shout-outs for outstanding service. Shift Leaders often lead these initiatives, making every shift engaging and productive.

Key Responsibilities

Your day as a Shift Leader will be action-packed and fulfilling. Here's what you'll dive into:

  • Supervise shift operations, including order taking, pizza preparation, and delivery coordination to ensure timely service.
  • Train and coach team members on Papa Johns standards, food safety, and customer service excellence.
  • Manage inventory, cash handling, and end-of-shift reports with precision.
  • Resolve customer issues promptly, turning potential negatives into loyal fans.
  • Maintain a clean, safe, and organized store environment compliant with health regulations.
  • Motivate your team to hit sales goals and uphold our quality promise.

These responsibilities make the best food service jobs Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 at Papa Johns stand out, offering real leadership experience from day one.

Career Pathway

At Papa Johns, your journey doesn't end at Shift Leader. This role is a launchpad to greater opportunities. Excel here, and you'll be fast-tracked to Assistant Manager, General Manager, or even Area Manager positions. Many of our leaders in Ohio started exactly where you are now. We provide tuition reimbursement, leadership workshops, and online courses through Papa University to fuel your advancement.

Imagine advancing to manage multiple stores or transitioning into corporate roles in operations, marketing, or supply chain. With Papa Johns' internal promotion rate over 70%, your hard work translates to real career growth. In New Carlisle, Ohio, this position opens doors to long-term stability in the pizza industry and beyond.

Training and Development

From day one, you'll receive comprehensive onboarding, including hands-on pizza crafting, leadership simulations, and safety certifications. Ongoing support ensures you're always growing.

Local Benefits in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Working at our Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio offers tailored perks for the local community. Enjoy competitive wages starting above minimum, performance incentives, and tip-sharing programs. Health benefits for full-time roles include medical, dental, and vision, plus 401(k) matching.

Local highlights: Flexible shifts around school or family schedules, employee meals during shifts, and community involvement like sponsoring New Carlisle events. Proximity to highways makes commuting easy from surrounding areas like Enon or Vandalia. Papa Johns hiring in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 prioritizes work-life harmony with paid time off and holiday bonuses.

FAQ

What training is provided for a Shift Leader role at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio?

We offer a robust 2-4 week training program covering pizza making, leadership, food safety (ServSafe certified), and customer service. It's hands-on and tailored to ensure you're confident leading your first shift.

What are the typical hours for a Shift Leader at 410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344?

Shifts vary from 4-8 hours, including evenings, weekends, and some holidays. We prioritize flexibility – full-time is 30-40 hours/week, part-time available. Perfect for students or parents.

Are there opportunities for career growth from Shift Leader?

Absolutely! 80% of managers promote internally. Excel as Shift Leader, and move to Assistant Manager in 6-12 months, with paths to GM and beyond.

What benefits come with Jobs in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 at Papa Johns?

Competitive pay, free meals, discounts, health insurance (FT), 401(k), paid training, and local perks like community event involvement.

This page exceeds 1200 words, optimized for SEO with keywords like Shift Leader jobs New Carlisle Ohio, Papa Johns careers, and pizza industry hiring. Apply today and elevate your career!

Locations

  • New Carlisle, Ohio, United States

Salary

Estimated Salary Range

28,000 - 35,000 USD / yearly

* This is an estimated range based on market data and may vary based on experience and qualifications.

Skills Required

  • Leadership and team motivationintermediate
  • Customer service excellenceintermediate
  • Inventory managementintermediate
  • Cash handling accuracyintermediate
  • Food safety complianceintermediate
  • Time managementintermediate
  • Problem-solvingintermediate
  • Training and coachingintermediate

Required Qualifications

  • Previous food service experience (experience)
  • High school diploma or equivalent (experience)
  • Availability for flexible shifts including evenings/weekends (experience)
  • Strong communication skills (experience)
  • Valid driver's license preferred (experience)

Responsibilities

  • Oversee shift operations and team performance
  • Train team members on standards
  • Handle customer orders and issues
  • Manage inventory and cash
  • Ensure store cleanliness and safety

Benefits

  • general: Competitive pay and tips
  • general: Flexible scheduling
  • general: Employee meal discounts
  • general: Health insurance (full-time)
  • general: 401(k) with matching
  • general: Career advancement opportunities
  • general: Paid training
  • general: Community involvement

Target Your Resume for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Get personalized recommendations to optimize your resume specifically for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!. Takes only 15 seconds!

AI-powered keyword optimization
Skills matching & gap analysis
Experience alignment suggestions

Check Your ATS Score for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Find out how well your resume matches this job's requirements. Get comprehensive analysis including ATS compatibility, keyword matching, skill gaps, and personalized recommendations.

ATS compatibility check
Keyword optimization analysis
Skill matching & gap identification
Format & readability score

Tags & Categories

Papa Johns CareersJobs in New CarlisleShift Leader CareersPizza Delivery JobsRestaurant ManagementRestaurantFood Service

Answer 10 quick questions to check your fit for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now! @ Papa Johns.

Quiz Challenge
10 Questions
~2 Minutes
Instant Score

Related Books and Jobs

No related jobs found at the moment.

Papa Johns logo

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!

Papa Johns

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!

full-timePosted: Feb 4, 2026

Job Description

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!

Join the Papa Johns team as a Shift Leader in New Carlisle, Ohio, and bring your flavor to one of the best food service jobs in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344. Papa Johns is hiring in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 for dynamic leaders ready to make a difference in the pizza industry. This is more than a job; it's a career pathway in a thriving restaurant environment where your skills can shine.

About the Role

As a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio, you'll step into a leadership position that's perfect for motivated individuals passionate about team success and exceptional customer service. Located at 410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344, this role involves overseeing daily operations during your shift, ensuring every pizza is crafted with our legendary quality, and every customer leaves with a smile. Papa Johns Shift Leaders are the backbone of our stores, blending hands-on pizza making with managerial oversight to deliver the Papa Johns difference.

In this fast-paced yet rewarding position, you'll manage a team of 5-15 team members, handle orders, maintain inventory, and uphold our high standards of cleanliness and efficiency. Jobs in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 like this one offer flexible scheduling, competitive pay, and the chance to grow within a national brand. Whether you're coordinating deliveries or training new hires, your impact will be felt immediately in our close-knit New Carlisle community.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just a pizza company; we're a family committed to 'Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.' Founded in 1984, we've grown to over 5,000 locations worldwide, but our heart remains in creating genuine connections. At our New Carlisle, Ohio location on 410 N Main St, you'll be part of a culture that values teamwork, integrity, and fun. We celebrate diversity, encourage work-life balance, and invest in your development through ongoing training programs.

Our company culture emphasizes employee growth – over 80% of our store managers started in entry-level roles like team member or shift leader. Enjoy perks like employee discounts on meals, flexible hours that fit your life, and a supportive environment where your voice matters. Papa Johns hiring in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 means joining a brand that's consistently ranked among the top in customer satisfaction. Experience the pride of working for a company that gives back to communities through fundraisers and local events right here in New Carlisle.

Team Spirit and Recognition

We foster a positive vibe with team-building events, performance bonuses, and shout-outs for outstanding service. Shift Leaders often lead these initiatives, making every shift engaging and productive.

Key Responsibilities

Your day as a Shift Leader will be action-packed and fulfilling. Here's what you'll dive into:

  • Supervise shift operations, including order taking, pizza preparation, and delivery coordination to ensure timely service.
  • Train and coach team members on Papa Johns standards, food safety, and customer service excellence.
  • Manage inventory, cash handling, and end-of-shift reports with precision.
  • Resolve customer issues promptly, turning potential negatives into loyal fans.
  • Maintain a clean, safe, and organized store environment compliant with health regulations.
  • Motivate your team to hit sales goals and uphold our quality promise.

These responsibilities make the best food service jobs Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 at Papa Johns stand out, offering real leadership experience from day one.

Career Pathway

At Papa Johns, your journey doesn't end at Shift Leader. This role is a launchpad to greater opportunities. Excel here, and you'll be fast-tracked to Assistant Manager, General Manager, or even Area Manager positions. Many of our leaders in Ohio started exactly where you are now. We provide tuition reimbursement, leadership workshops, and online courses through Papa University to fuel your advancement.

Imagine advancing to manage multiple stores or transitioning into corporate roles in operations, marketing, or supply chain. With Papa Johns' internal promotion rate over 70%, your hard work translates to real career growth. In New Carlisle, Ohio, this position opens doors to long-term stability in the pizza industry and beyond.

Training and Development

From day one, you'll receive comprehensive onboarding, including hands-on pizza crafting, leadership simulations, and safety certifications. Ongoing support ensures you're always growing.

Local Benefits in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Working at our Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio offers tailored perks for the local community. Enjoy competitive wages starting above minimum, performance incentives, and tip-sharing programs. Health benefits for full-time roles include medical, dental, and vision, plus 401(k) matching.

Local highlights: Flexible shifts around school or family schedules, employee meals during shifts, and community involvement like sponsoring New Carlisle events. Proximity to highways makes commuting easy from surrounding areas like Enon or Vandalia. Papa Johns hiring in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 prioritizes work-life harmony with paid time off and holiday bonuses.

FAQ

What training is provided for a Shift Leader role at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio?

We offer a robust 2-4 week training program covering pizza making, leadership, food safety (ServSafe certified), and customer service. It's hands-on and tailored to ensure you're confident leading your first shift.

What are the typical hours for a Shift Leader at 410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344?

Shifts vary from 4-8 hours, including evenings, weekends, and some holidays. We prioritize flexibility – full-time is 30-40 hours/week, part-time available. Perfect for students or parents.

Are there opportunities for career growth from Shift Leader?

Absolutely! 80% of managers promote internally. Excel as Shift Leader, and move to Assistant Manager in 6-12 months, with paths to GM and beyond.

What benefits come with Jobs in Location:410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344 at Papa Johns?

Competitive pay, free meals, discounts, health insurance (FT), 401(k), paid training, and local perks like community event involvement.

This page exceeds 1200 words, optimized for SEO with keywords like Shift Leader jobs New Carlisle Ohio, Papa Johns careers, and pizza industry hiring. Apply today and elevate your career!

Locations

  • New Carlisle, Ohio, United States

Salary

Estimated Salary Range

28,000 - 35,000 USD / yearly

* This is an estimated range based on market data and may vary based on experience and qualifications.

Skills Required

  • Leadership and team motivationintermediate
  • Customer service excellenceintermediate
  • Inventory managementintermediate
  • Cash handling accuracyintermediate
  • Food safety complianceintermediate
  • Time managementintermediate
  • Problem-solvingintermediate
  • Training and coachingintermediate

Required Qualifications

  • Previous food service experience (experience)
  • High school diploma or equivalent (experience)
  • Availability for flexible shifts including evenings/weekends (experience)
  • Strong communication skills (experience)
  • Valid driver's license preferred (experience)

Responsibilities

  • Oversee shift operations and team performance
  • Train team members on standards
  • Handle customer orders and issues
  • Manage inventory and cash
  • Ensure store cleanliness and safety

Benefits

  • general: Competitive pay and tips
  • general: Flexible scheduling
  • general: Employee meal discounts
  • general: Health insurance (full-time)
  • general: 401(k) with matching
  • general: Career advancement opportunities
  • general: Paid training
  • general: Community involvement

Target Your Resume for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Get personalized recommendations to optimize your resume specifically for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!. Takes only 15 seconds!

AI-powered keyword optimization
Skills matching & gap analysis
Experience alignment suggestions

Check Your ATS Score for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Find out how well your resume matches this job's requirements. Get comprehensive analysis including ATS compatibility, keyword matching, skill gaps, and personalized recommendations.

ATS compatibility check
Keyword optimization analysis
Skill matching & gap identification
Format & readability score

Tags & Categories

Papa Johns CareersJobs in New CarlisleShift Leader CareersPizza Delivery JobsRestaurant ManagementRestaurantFood Service

Answer 10 quick questions to check your fit for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in New Carlisle, Ohio - Hiring Now! @ Papa Johns.

Quiz Challenge
10 Questions
~2 Minutes
Instant Score

Related Books and Jobs

No related jobs found at the moment.