Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

Join the Papa Johns team as a Shift Leader at our bustling location at 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202. If you're passionate about pizza, leadership, and creating memorable customer experiences, this is your chance to shine in one of the best food service jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana. Papa Johns is actively hiring in Indianapolis, Indiana, and we're looking for dynamic individuals to lead our shifts and drive our store's success. Discover jobs in 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202 that offer more than just a paycheck—they provide a pathway to a thriving career in the pizza industry.

About the Role

As a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana, you'll be the heartbeat of our store during peak hours. This isn't just a job; it's an opportunity to step into a leadership position where your energy and skills make a real difference. You'll oversee team members, ensure top-notch pizza quality, and deliver the legendary customer service Papa Johns is known for. Located at 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202, our store serves the vibrant Indianapolis community, from downtown workers to families enjoying game nights. Papa Johns hiring in 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202 means joining a team that's all about Bring Your Flavor—bringing your unique style to every shift.

In this role, expect a fast-paced environment where no two shifts are the same. You'll handle everything from pizza prep to order fulfillment, all while motivating your crew to hit sales targets and maintain our high standards. With Papa Johns' commitment to quality ingredients and innovative menu items, you'll be proud to lead a team crafting better-ingredient pizzas that keep customers coming back. This position is perfect for those seeking jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana with real responsibility and room to grow.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just another pizza chain—it's a global powerhouse with over 5,000 locations worldwide, built on a foundation of quality, integrity, and community. Founded in 1984, we've grown into a beloved brand because we live by our motto: Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. At our Indianapolis, Indiana location, you'll be part of a culture that values teamwork, fun, and personal development. Our company culture emphasizes work-life balance, with flexible scheduling that fits your life, whether you're a student, parent, or career changer.

What sets Papa Johns apart? We invest in our people. From day one, you'll receive hands-on training through our renowned Papa Johns University, covering leadership, operations, and customer service. Our inclusive environment celebrates diversity, with team-building events, pizza parties, and recognition programs that make every shift enjoyable. In Indianapolis, Indiana, Papa Johns stands out among best food service jobs in 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202, offering competitive pay, tips, and bonuses that can boost your earnings significantly. Plus, enjoy perks like free pizza on shifts, employee discounts, and a supportive management team that's invested in your success.

We're more than a job; we're a family. Employees rave about the camaraderie, the constant learning, and the pride in serving fresh, high-quality pizzas to the Indianapolis community. Whether it's cheering on the Colts or hosting local events, our store at 955 Indiana Ave is deeply rooted in Indianapolis pride.

Key Responsibilities

As Shift Leader, your role is pivotal in ensuring smooth operations. Here's what you'll do:

• Lead a team of 5-15 crew members during shifts, delegating tasks and providing real-time coaching.
• Oversee food preparation, ensuring every pizza meets Papa Johns' strict quality standards using fresh dough, premium toppings, and our signature sauce.
• Manage customer orders, handle payments, and resolve issues to maintain 100% satisfaction.
• Monitor inventory, place orders, and maintain a clean, safe store environment compliant with health regulations.
• Drive sales through upselling specials, promotions, and our innovative online ordering system.
• Train new hires on Papa Johns procedures, fostering a positive team culture.
• Handle opening and closing duties, including cash reconciliation and equipment checks.

These responsibilities build your skills in leadership, operations, and customer service, making you indispensable in the pizza industry.

Career Pathway

At Papa Johns, a Shift Leader role is your launchpad to bigger things. 70% of our store managers started in entry-level positions like this one. Advance to Assistant Manager in 6-12 months, then General Manager, where you'll run the entire store with six-figure earning potential through bonuses and profit-sharing. From there, opportunities abound in district management, operations, marketing, or even corporate roles at our Atlanta headquarters.

We provide clear pathways: complete leadership certifications via Papa Johns University, exceed performance metrics, and you're promoted. Many Indianapolis team members have climbed the ranks, now leading multiple stores. This is a career in the pizza industry, not a dead-end job. With ongoing training in digital tools, supply chain, and business management, you'll gain transferable skills for any food service leadership role. Join Papa Johns careers in Indianapolis, Indiana and build a future with unlimited potential.

Local Benefits in 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202

Working at our Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana offers tailored perks for the local scene. Enjoy flexible hours around IU Health events, Colts games, and Indiana Pacers excitement. Proximity to downtown means quick commutes via bus or bike, with ample parking. Earn tips averaging $5-10/hour extra in this high-traffic area.

• Competitive hourly wage plus tips and performance bonuses.
• Flexible scheduling: full-time, part-time, weekends, evenings.
• Free employee meals and 50% off for friends/family.
• Health, dental, vision insurance for full-time (after qualifying period).
• 401(k) with company match.
• Paid time off and holiday pay.
• Employee assistance program for wellness.
• Discounts at local Indianapolis partners.

Plus, contribute to community initiatives like school fundraisers and neighborhood clean-ups, giving back to Indianapolis, Indiana.

FAQ

What training do I receive as a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis?

You'll get comprehensive onboarding through Papa Johns University, including 40+ hours of hands-on training in leadership, food safety, and operations. Ongoing coaching ensures you're set for success.

What are the typical hours for this role?

Shifts vary: 4-8 hours, evenings/weekends peak. Flexible scheduling accommodates school or other commitments, averaging 25-40 hours/week.

Are there advancement opportunities?

Absolutely! Fast-track to management with proven performance. Many Shift Leaders become GMs within a year.

Do I need prior experience for Papa Johns Shift Leader jobs in Indianapolis?

Preferred but not required. We train motivated individuals passionate about team leadership and customer service.

Ready to bring your flavor? Apply now for Shift Leader positions at Papa Johns in 955 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202. Papa Johns hiring in Indianapolis, Indiana—your best food service career starts here!