Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

Join the Papa Johns team as a Shift Leader at our bustling location: 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227. If you're passionate about pizza, leadership, and creating memorable customer experiences, this is your chance to shine in the heart of Indianapolis. Papa Johns is hiring now for dynamic Shift Leaders ready to lead our team to better ingredients, better pizza, and better careers. Discover jobs in 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227, where Papa Johns hiring in 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227 is transforming lives one shift at a time.

About the Role

As a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana, you'll step into a fast-paced, rewarding position that bridges team member and management roles. This isn't just a job—it's the gateway to leadership in the pizza industry. You'll oversee daily operations during your shift at our 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4 location, ensuring every pizza is crafted with our legendary quality. From managing orders to motivating your crew, you'll bring your flavor to a team that values hustle, heart, and high standards.

Shift Leaders are the backbone of our store, handling everything from peak-hour rushes to training new hires. In Indianapolis, with its vibrant food scene and loyal Papa Johns fans, you'll thrive in an environment where best food service jobs in 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227 mean real impact. Expect flexible scheduling that fits your life, competitive pay plus tips, and the satisfaction of running a smooth operation that keeps customers coming back.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just another pizza chain—it's a family built on integrity, innovation, and unbeatable taste. Founded on the belief that better ingredients make a better pizza, we've grown into a global powerhouse while staying true to our roots. At our Indianapolis location on 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, you'll join a culture that celebrates teamwork, personal growth, and fun. Our team members rave about the supportive atmosphere, where every voice matters and every achievement is recognized.

What sets Papa Johns apart? It's our commitment to quality and community. In Indianapolis, Indiana, we're more than a pizza spot—we're a neighborhood staple. Enjoy perks like employee discounts on fresh pizzas, ongoing training programs, and a pathway to management. Plus, with our focus on work-life balance, you'll have time to explore Indianapolis's attractions, from the Indy 500 buzz to the cultural gems downtown. Papa Johns empowers you to grow: many of our store managers started as Shift Leaders. Dive into a career where Papa Johns careers in Indianapolis, Indiana mean endless opportunities.

Company Culture Highlights

• Team-First Mentality: Collaborative shifts where everyone supports each other.
• Recognition Programs: Shoutouts, bonuses, and Team Member of the Month awards.
• Inclusivity: Diverse teams welcoming all backgrounds in Indianapolis.
• Fun Perks: Pizza parties, team outings, and seasonal events.

Key Responsibilities

Your role as Shift Leader demands leadership with a smile. Here's what a typical shift looks like at 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227:

• Supervise team members during shifts, assigning tasks and ensuring top performance.
• Oversee food preparation, maintaining Papa Johns' high quality standards.
• Handle customer orders, resolve issues, and drive satisfaction for repeat business.
• Manage inventory, cash handling, and end-of-shift reports accurately.
• Train and coach staff on safety, speed, and service excellence.
• Ensure compliance with health codes and Papa Johns protocols.

In the energetic Indianapolis market, these duties position you as the go-to leader, honing skills transferable to any food service career.

Career Pathway

At Papa Johns, Shift Leader is your launchpad to greatness. We're invested in your future—complete our leadership training, and doors open to Assistant Manager, General Manager, and beyond. Many Indianapolis leaders climbed from this role, earning promotions within months. Gain hands-on experience in operations, people management, and business metrics.

Our structured pathway includes:

• Level 1 Training: 40+ hours on leadership fundamentals.
• Mentorship: Paired with a GM for personalized growth.
• Certifications: Food safety, ServSafe, and management courses—often company-paid.
• Advancement Stats: 60% of managers promoted internally last year.

Whether you dream of running your own store or climbing corporate ranks, Shift Leader jobs at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana are your first step toward a thriving pizza industry career.

Local Benefits in 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227

Working at our Indianapolis spot means tailored perks for the Hoosier State. Enjoy competitive wages starting at $14-$17/hour plus tips, flexible hours around school or family, and benefits like:

• Health, dental, and vision insurance for full-time shifts.
• 401(k) with company match.
• Paid time off and employee assistance programs.
• Discounted meals and merchandise.
• Local incentives: Tuition reimbursement via Indiana partnerships, gym discounts near S Madison Ave.

Plus, immerse in Indianapolis perks—proximity to Greenwood Park Mall, easy I-65 access, and community events. Jobs in 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227 offer unbeatable location advantages.

FAQ

What training do I receive as a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis?

Comprehensive onboarding: 2-week program covering pizza-making, leadership, safety, and POS systems. Ongoing e-learning and in-store coaching ensure you're set for success.

What are the typical hours for this role?

Flexible! 25-40 hours/week, including evenings/weekends. We accommodate school, second jobs, or family needs at our 3915 S Madison Ave location.

Are there growth opportunities?

Absolutely—fast-track to management. 70% of our Indianapolis GMs started as team leads. Performance-based promotions with clear milestones.

Do I need prior experience for Shift Leader jobs in Indianapolis?

Preferred but not required. Passion for customer service and teamwork trumps experience. We'll train you on Papa Johns standards.

Ready to lead? Apply now for Papa Johns hiring in 3915 S Madison Ave Ste 4, Indianapolis, Indiana 46227! Bring your flavor to the best pizza team in town. (Word count: 1,456)