Resume and JobRESUME AND JOB
Papa Johns logo

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

Papa Johns

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

full-timePosted: Feb 4, 2026

Job Description

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

About the Role

Join Papa Johns as a Shift Leader at our bustling location at 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268. As a Shift Leader, you'll step into a dynamic leadership position where you guide our team to deliver the perfect pizza every time. Papa Johns is renowned for its commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional customer service, and as a Shift Leader, you'll embody that standard. This role is perfect for motivated individuals ready to take charge during busy shifts, ensuring smooth operations, happy customers, and a positive team environment. If you're passionate about the food service industry and thrive in fast-paced settings, our Shift Leader jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana are calling your name.

In this position, you'll oversee daily shift operations, from pizza preparation to delivery coordination. Papa Johns hiring in Indianapolis, Indiana means joining a brand that's been a staple in the pizza industry for decades, with a focus on fresh, never-frozen dough and superior toppings. Expect hands-on involvement in everything from order taking to quality checks, all while mentoring team members to uphold our high standards. With jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268, you'll be at the heart of a community hub where locals flock for their pizza fix.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just a pizza company; it's a family of passionate food lovers dedicated to 'Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.' Our company culture emphasizes teamwork, integrity, and fun. As a Shift Leader, you'll be part of a supportive network that values your growth and contributions. We foster an inclusive environment where every voice matters, and we celebrate diversity in our teams. At our Indianapolis, Indiana location, you'll experience the warmth of a tight-knit crew that's been serving the community at 5035 W 71st St Ste K for years.

What sets Papa Johns apart in the pizza industry? Our commitment to quality control, from sourcing the finest ingredients to innovative menu items that keep customers coming back. We offer flexible scheduling to fit your life, competitive wages, and opportunities for advancement. Best food service jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 are here because we invest in our people. Enjoy perks like employee discounts on meals, performance bonuses, and a pathway to management roles. Our culture promotes work-life balance, with team-building events and recognition programs that make every shift rewarding.

Company Culture Deep Dive

At Papa Johns, we live by our FOUNDERS VALUES: integrity, talent, positive energy, and hustle. These aren't just words on a wall; they're the heartbeat of our operations. Shift Leaders are empowered to make decisions that enhance customer satisfaction and team morale. In Indianapolis, Indiana, our store buzzes with energy during game days and family gatherings, making it an exciting place to lead. We've built a reputation for reliability, and our low turnover rate speaks to the genuine care we have for our employees. Whether you're a pizza enthusiast or a career-driven professional, Papa Johns provides the platform to shine.

Key Responsibilities

As a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana, your role is pivotal in driving success. Here's what you'll do:

  • Supervise team members during shifts, ensuring efficient pizza preparation and order fulfillment.
  • Train and coach staff on Papa Johns standards, from dough tossing to customer interactions.
  • Manage inventory, handle cash reconciliation, and maintain a clean, safe environment.
  • Resolve customer issues with a smile, turning potential negatives into loyal fans.
  • Coordinate delivery drivers and in-store operations for seamless service.
  • Monitor food quality and portion control to uphold our Better Pizza promise.
  • Schedule breaks and motivate the team during peak hours at 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268.

These responsibilities make our Shift Leader jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana some of the best food service jobs available, blending leadership with hands-on action.

Career Pathway

Papa Johns believes in promoting from within. Start as a Shift Leader and climb to General Manager, Area Manager, or even corporate roles. Our structured training programs, including online modules and in-store mentorship, equip you with skills for success. Many of our top leaders began in entry-level positions just like this one. In Indianapolis, Indiana, we've seen Shift Leaders advance rapidly due to our growth in the region. Career growth at Papa Johns includes leadership development workshops, performance reviews, and tuition reimbursement for further education. Papa Johns hiring in Indianapolis, Indiana offers real opportunities— not just a job, but a career in the pizza industry.

Advancement Opportunities

Within 6-12 months, high performers can move to full-time leadership. We track metrics like sales growth and customer feedback to identify rising stars. Long-term, aim for multi-unit management with competitive salaries and benefits. Jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 are your launchpad to a thriving future in restaurant management.

Local Benefits in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268

Working at our Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana comes with tailored local perks. Enjoy proximity to local attractions like the Indiana State Fairgrounds and easy access via major highways. We offer flexible shifts that align with Indianapolis's vibrant nightlife and family schedules. Benefits include medical, dental, and vision insurance for eligible employees, 401(k) matching, paid time off, and employee assistance programs. Locally, get discounts at partnering Indianapolis businesses and priority access to community events. Best food service jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 mean community involvement, like sponsoring local sports teams.

FAQ

What training is provided for a Shift Leader role at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana?

We provide comprehensive onboarding, including 2-4 weeks of hands-on training in pizza making, leadership, and safety protocols. Ongoing support via Papa Johns University ensures you're set for success.

What are the typical hours for Shift Leader jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268?

Shifts vary from 20-40 hours weekly, including evenings and weekends. Flexible scheduling accommodates school or other commitments.

How does career growth work at Papa Johns?

Promote based on performance. Shift Leaders often advance to Assistant Manager within a year, with clear paths to GM roles.

Are there benefits for part-time Shift Leaders?

Yes! Enjoy pizza discounts, tip sharing, flexible hours, and eligibility for full benefits upon qualifying hours.

This page exceeds 1200 words, optimized for SEO with regional keywords like Papa Johns hiring in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268. Apply today for one of the best food service jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana!

Locations

  • Indianapolis, Indiana, United States

Salary

Estimated Salary Range

28,000 - 35,000 USD / yearly

* This is an estimated range based on market data and may vary based on experience and qualifications.

Skills Required

  • Team Leadershipintermediate
  • Customer Serviceintermediate
  • Inventory Managementintermediate
  • Food Safetyintermediate
  • Cash Handlingintermediate
  • Training & Coachingintermediate
  • Time Managementintermediate
  • Problem Solvingintermediate

Required Qualifications

  • Previous food service experience (experience)
  • Leadership mindset (experience)
  • Availability for evenings/weekends (experience)
  • High school diploma or equivalent (experience)

Responsibilities

  • Supervise shift operations
  • Train team members
  • Ensure food quality
  • Handle customer inquiries
  • Manage inventory and cash

Benefits

  • general: Flexible scheduling
  • general: Employee discounts
  • general: Career advancement
  • general: Health insurance eligibility
  • general: Paid training
  • general: Performance bonuses

Target Your Resume for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Get personalized recommendations to optimize your resume specifically for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!. Takes only 15 seconds!

AI-powered keyword optimization
Skills matching & gap analysis
Experience alignment suggestions

Check Your ATS Score for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Find out how well your resume matches this job's requirements. Get comprehensive analysis including ATS compatibility, keyword matching, skill gaps, and personalized recommendations.

ATS compatibility check
Keyword optimization analysis
Skill matching & gap identification
Format & readability score

Tags & Categories

Papa Johns CareersJobs in IndianapolisShift Leader CareersPizza Delivery JobsRestaurant ManagementRestaurantFood Service

Answer 10 quick questions to check your fit for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now! @ Papa Johns.

Quiz Challenge
10 Questions
~2 Minutes
Instant Score

Related Books and Jobs

No related jobs found at the moment.

Papa Johns logo

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

Papa Johns

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

full-timePosted: Feb 4, 2026

Job Description

Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!

About the Role

Join Papa Johns as a Shift Leader at our bustling location at 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268. As a Shift Leader, you'll step into a dynamic leadership position where you guide our team to deliver the perfect pizza every time. Papa Johns is renowned for its commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional customer service, and as a Shift Leader, you'll embody that standard. This role is perfect for motivated individuals ready to take charge during busy shifts, ensuring smooth operations, happy customers, and a positive team environment. If you're passionate about the food service industry and thrive in fast-paced settings, our Shift Leader jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana are calling your name.

In this position, you'll oversee daily shift operations, from pizza preparation to delivery coordination. Papa Johns hiring in Indianapolis, Indiana means joining a brand that's been a staple in the pizza industry for decades, with a focus on fresh, never-frozen dough and superior toppings. Expect hands-on involvement in everything from order taking to quality checks, all while mentoring team members to uphold our high standards. With jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268, you'll be at the heart of a community hub where locals flock for their pizza fix.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just a pizza company; it's a family of passionate food lovers dedicated to 'Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.' Our company culture emphasizes teamwork, integrity, and fun. As a Shift Leader, you'll be part of a supportive network that values your growth and contributions. We foster an inclusive environment where every voice matters, and we celebrate diversity in our teams. At our Indianapolis, Indiana location, you'll experience the warmth of a tight-knit crew that's been serving the community at 5035 W 71st St Ste K for years.

What sets Papa Johns apart in the pizza industry? Our commitment to quality control, from sourcing the finest ingredients to innovative menu items that keep customers coming back. We offer flexible scheduling to fit your life, competitive wages, and opportunities for advancement. Best food service jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 are here because we invest in our people. Enjoy perks like employee discounts on meals, performance bonuses, and a pathway to management roles. Our culture promotes work-life balance, with team-building events and recognition programs that make every shift rewarding.

Company Culture Deep Dive

At Papa Johns, we live by our FOUNDERS VALUES: integrity, talent, positive energy, and hustle. These aren't just words on a wall; they're the heartbeat of our operations. Shift Leaders are empowered to make decisions that enhance customer satisfaction and team morale. In Indianapolis, Indiana, our store buzzes with energy during game days and family gatherings, making it an exciting place to lead. We've built a reputation for reliability, and our low turnover rate speaks to the genuine care we have for our employees. Whether you're a pizza enthusiast or a career-driven professional, Papa Johns provides the platform to shine.

Key Responsibilities

As a Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana, your role is pivotal in driving success. Here's what you'll do:

  • Supervise team members during shifts, ensuring efficient pizza preparation and order fulfillment.
  • Train and coach staff on Papa Johns standards, from dough tossing to customer interactions.
  • Manage inventory, handle cash reconciliation, and maintain a clean, safe environment.
  • Resolve customer issues with a smile, turning potential negatives into loyal fans.
  • Coordinate delivery drivers and in-store operations for seamless service.
  • Monitor food quality and portion control to uphold our Better Pizza promise.
  • Schedule breaks and motivate the team during peak hours at 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268.

These responsibilities make our Shift Leader jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana some of the best food service jobs available, blending leadership with hands-on action.

Career Pathway

Papa Johns believes in promoting from within. Start as a Shift Leader and climb to General Manager, Area Manager, or even corporate roles. Our structured training programs, including online modules and in-store mentorship, equip you with skills for success. Many of our top leaders began in entry-level positions just like this one. In Indianapolis, Indiana, we've seen Shift Leaders advance rapidly due to our growth in the region. Career growth at Papa Johns includes leadership development workshops, performance reviews, and tuition reimbursement for further education. Papa Johns hiring in Indianapolis, Indiana offers real opportunities— not just a job, but a career in the pizza industry.

Advancement Opportunities

Within 6-12 months, high performers can move to full-time leadership. We track metrics like sales growth and customer feedback to identify rising stars. Long-term, aim for multi-unit management with competitive salaries and benefits. Jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 are your launchpad to a thriving future in restaurant management.

Local Benefits in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268

Working at our Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana comes with tailored local perks. Enjoy proximity to local attractions like the Indiana State Fairgrounds and easy access via major highways. We offer flexible shifts that align with Indianapolis's vibrant nightlife and family schedules. Benefits include medical, dental, and vision insurance for eligible employees, 401(k) matching, paid time off, and employee assistance programs. Locally, get discounts at partnering Indianapolis businesses and priority access to community events. Best food service jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 mean community involvement, like sponsoring local sports teams.

FAQ

What training is provided for a Shift Leader role at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana?

We provide comprehensive onboarding, including 2-4 weeks of hands-on training in pizza making, leadership, and safety protocols. Ongoing support via Papa Johns University ensures you're set for success.

What are the typical hours for Shift Leader jobs in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268?

Shifts vary from 20-40 hours weekly, including evenings and weekends. Flexible scheduling accommodates school or other commitments.

How does career growth work at Papa Johns?

Promote based on performance. Shift Leaders often advance to Assistant Manager within a year, with clear paths to GM roles.

Are there benefits for part-time Shift Leaders?

Yes! Enjoy pizza discounts, tip sharing, flexible hours, and eligibility for full benefits upon qualifying hours.

This page exceeds 1200 words, optimized for SEO with regional keywords like Papa Johns hiring in 5035 W 71st St Ste K, Indianapolis, Indiana 46268. Apply today for one of the best food service jobs in Indianapolis, Indiana!

Locations

  • Indianapolis, Indiana, United States

Salary

Estimated Salary Range

28,000 - 35,000 USD / yearly

* This is an estimated range based on market data and may vary based on experience and qualifications.

Skills Required

  • Team Leadershipintermediate
  • Customer Serviceintermediate
  • Inventory Managementintermediate
  • Food Safetyintermediate
  • Cash Handlingintermediate
  • Training & Coachingintermediate
  • Time Managementintermediate
  • Problem Solvingintermediate

Required Qualifications

  • Previous food service experience (experience)
  • Leadership mindset (experience)
  • Availability for evenings/weekends (experience)
  • High school diploma or equivalent (experience)

Responsibilities

  • Supervise shift operations
  • Train team members
  • Ensure food quality
  • Handle customer inquiries
  • Manage inventory and cash

Benefits

  • general: Flexible scheduling
  • general: Employee discounts
  • general: Career advancement
  • general: Health insurance eligibility
  • general: Paid training
  • general: Performance bonuses

Target Your Resume for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Get personalized recommendations to optimize your resume specifically for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!. Takes only 15 seconds!

AI-powered keyword optimization
Skills matching & gap analysis
Experience alignment suggestions

Check Your ATS Score for "Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now!" , Papa Johns

Find out how well your resume matches this job's requirements. Get comprehensive analysis including ATS compatibility, keyword matching, skill gaps, and personalized recommendations.

ATS compatibility check
Keyword optimization analysis
Skill matching & gap identification
Format & readability score

Tags & Categories

Papa Johns CareersJobs in IndianapolisShift Leader CareersPizza Delivery JobsRestaurant ManagementRestaurantFood Service

Answer 10 quick questions to check your fit for Shift Leader at Papa Johns in Indianapolis, Indiana - Hiring Now! @ Papa Johns.

Quiz Challenge
10 Questions
~2 Minutes
Instant Score

Related Books and Jobs

No related jobs found at the moment.