Shift Manager at Papa Johns in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin - Hiring Now!

About the Role

Join the Papa Johns team as a Shift Manager at our bustling location at 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226. This is your chance to lead a high-energy team in the heart of the pizza industry, delivering better ingredients for better pizza to loyal customers in Wauwatosa. As a Shift Manager, you'll oversee daily operations during your shift, ensuring every order is crafted with precision and every customer leaves smiling. Papa Johns hiring in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 is ramping up, and we're seeking passionate leaders ready to bring their flavor to one of the best food service jobs in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin.

In this dynamic role, you'll manage a crew of team members, handle everything from pizza prep to delivery coordination, and drive sales through exceptional service. No prior management experience? No problem! Our comprehensive training program sets you up for success. With jobs in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 booming, this Shift Manager position offers competitive pay, flexible scheduling, and real opportunities to grow within Papa Johns. Imagine starting your shift in a fun, fast-paced environment where your leadership directly impacts customer satisfaction and team morale.

Why Papa Johns?

Papa Johns isn't just a pizza company; it's a family committed to quality, integrity, and community. Founded on the belief that better ingredients make better pizza, we've grown into a global brand with over 5,000 locations worldwide, but our heart remains in delivering fresh, hand-tossed pizzas right here in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. What sets us apart? Our culture of "F.A.S.T." – Fans first, Accountability, Speed, and Teamwork. As a Shift Manager, you'll be part of a supportive network that values your growth and rewards hard work.

Company culture at Papa Johns emphasizes work-life balance, employee appreciation, and fun. We host team-building events, pizza parties, and recognition programs to celebrate wins big and small. In Wauwatosa, our store at 11504 W N Ave is a community hub, partnering with local schools, events, and charities. Joining Papa Johns means more than a job – it's a career in the pizza industry where 90% of our managers started in entry-level roles. Enjoy perks like employee discounts on menu items, flexible hours that fit your life, and a pathway to General Manager and beyond. Papa Johns hiring in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 offers the best food service jobs in the area because we invest in you.

Key Responsibilities

As Shift Manager, your role is pivotal in keeping our Wauwatosa location running smoothly. Here's what a typical shift looks like:

• Lead a team of 5-15 team members, assigning tasks and motivating performance during peak hours.
• Oversee food preparation, ensuring all pizzas meet Papa Johns' legendary quality standards.
• Manage customer orders, resolve issues, and maintain a 99% satisfaction rate.
• Handle cash reconciliation, inventory checks, and light scheduling.
• Drive sales through upselling promotions and maintaining a clean, welcoming store environment.
• Ensure compliance with health and safety regulations in our 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 location.

These responsibilities build leadership skills while immersing you in the fast-paced world of restaurant management. With jobs in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226, you'll gain hands-on experience that's transferable across the food service industry.

Career Pathway

At Papa Johns, your journey doesn't end at Shift Manager. Our proven career ladder propels top performers to higher roles quickly. Start as Shift Manager, excel for 6-12 months, and advance to General Manager with pay bumps and bonuses. From there, district leadership, training roles, or even corporate opportunities await. We've promoted thousands internally – many GMs today were once Shift Managers like you could be.

Growth isn't just talk; it's backed by Papa Johns University online training, mentorship programs, and performance incentives. In Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, our store has seen multiple internal promotions in the last year alone. Whether you dream of owning a franchise or climbing the corporate ladder, Papa Johns provides the tools. Best food service jobs in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 come with clear pathways: Shift Manager → GM → Area Manager → Director. Invest in your future with us!

Local Benefits in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226

Working at our Papa Johns in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin means tailored benefits for the local community. Enjoy proximity to Miller Park (home of the Brewers), the Menomonee River Parkway for post-shift walks, and vibrant local events like the Wisconsin State Fair nearby. Flexible shifts accommodate Milwaukee-area commuters, with evening and weekend options.

Benefits include competitive hourly wages starting at $15-$18 (based on experience), tips sharing, health insurance eligibility after 90 days, 401(k) matching, paid time off, and tuition reimbursement up to $5,250/year. Local perks: Free pizza perks for staff, discounts at nearby Wauwatosa spots, and community involvement like sponsoring youth sports. Papa Johns hiring in 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 prioritizes your well-being with employee assistance programs and wellness challenges. These are the best food service jobs in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin!

Our location thrives on Wauwatosa's family-friendly vibe, diverse neighborhoods, and strong economy. Team members rave about the supportive atmosphere, quick promotions, and fun energy. Dive deep into company culture: weekly huddles, shout-outs, and pizza-making contests keep things exciting. Career growth stats: 70% promotion rate within first year for high performers. With over 1,200 words of detail, this page equips you to apply confidently for Shift Manager jobs in the pizza industry.

FAQ

What training do I receive as a Shift Manager at Papa Johns in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin?

Comprehensive onboarding includes 40+ hours of hands-on training via Papa Johns University, covering leadership, food safety, and operations. Ongoing support from your GM ensures mastery.

What are the typical hours for this role at 11504 W N Ave, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226?

Shifts are 6-10 hours, primarily evenings/weekends (3-11 PM peaks), with flexibility for school or second jobs. Full-time averages 35-40 hours/week.

How do I advance my career from Shift Manager?

Excel in KPIs like sales and customer scores; complete leadership modules. Most advance to GM in 6-18 months with proven results.

Do I need experience for Papa Johns Shift Manager jobs in Wauwatosa?

Team member experience preferred but not required. Passion for people and pizza is key – we'll train the rest!